Comparison

Smart Lock vs Video Doorbell: Which Should You Buy First? (November 2026)

Updated on · By the Get Security Camera team

Buy a smart lock first if controlling entry is your main concern, or a video doorbell first if you need to see and speak with visitors. Your home's biggest gap should decide between access control and doorstep monitoring.

On this page (9 sections)
  1. Smart lock vs video doorbell: which solves the bigger gap?
  2. What does a smart lock do better?
  3. What does a video doorbell do better?
  4. Should you control the door or watch the porch first?
  5. Which Schlage Encode trim should you choose?
  6. When does a wired doorbell need a transformer?
  7. Smart lock vs video doorbell for renters and guests
  8. What should you buy first if you plan to own both?
  9. Smart lock vs video doorbell: final decision

Buy a smart lock first if controlling entry is your main concern, or a video doorbell first if you need to see and speak with visitors. The choice is about the gap you want to close, and that gap differs for almost every home.

A smart lock can manage access codes, remote locking and lock history. It can also give a family member, guest or service visitor a way in without handing over a physical key.

A video doorbell can show visitors, detect activity and support two-way audio. It can help you check whether a parcel has arrived, confirm who is waiting, or decide whether a doorstep issue needs your attention now.

Neither device covers the other job. A smart lock does not tell you who is standing outside, and a video doorbell does not open or secure the door by itself.

Think about the moments that cause trouble in your home. Those moments might involve keys, missed locking, guest access, deliveries, visitors, or a porch you cannot see from inside.

If your trouble happens after someone is approved to enter, a smart lock is likely to help you sooner. If your trouble happens before you decide whether to answer, a video doorbell is likely to help you sooner.

This comparison looks at daily use, installation, power, privacy and the order that makes sense for different homes. It also separates the products that control entry from the products that monitor the doorstep.

Daily use matters because a device can look useful in a list yet fit badly into a normal routine. Power matters because batteries, wiring and charging create different kinds of upkeep.

Privacy matters because access codes, lock history, video clips, notifications and voice control involve personal information. A careful choice should account for daily use, not only the features shown in a summary.

The sections ahead explain what each device does well, where the limits sit, and which purchase order suits renters, families, hosts, and people who mainly want better awareness outside the front door.

Schlage Encode Smart WiFi Deadbolt LockBest for remote entry control

Schlage Encode Smart WiFi Deadbolt Lock

9.7/10Our score

See it on Amazon

aosu 5MP Ultra HD Wireless & WiredBest for doorstep visibility

aosu 5MP Ultra HD Wireless & Wired

9.7/10Our score

See it on Amazon

Smart lock vs video doorbell: which solves the bigger gap?

Choose the smart lock for access control, and choose the video doorbell for visitor monitoring. Neither device replaces the other because each protects a different part of the entry process.

A smart lock changes how people get inside. Depending on the model, you can use a touchscreen keypad, a physical key or an app.

The keypad helps when your hands are full or you want a code that can be changed later. The physical key works as a backup, while the app can support remote action and records of lock activity.

A video doorbell changes what you can see and hear outside. It can help you check a delivery, speak with a visitor and review recorded activity without opening the front door.

That outside view matters when parcels, visitors or passing activity are hard to judge from inside. It can also help you decide whether someone needs a response now or can wait.

The smart lock works at the point of entry, where permission and locking matter most. The video doorbell works before that point, where identification and awareness matter most.

If you often forget to lock the door, start with the smart lock. Auto-lock, remote control and notifications can reduce that repeat worry.

If you often do not know who is at the door, start with the video doorbell. Live view, alerts, two-way audio and recorded clips can make the doorstep less uncertain.

Some homes have both problems, and some have only one. A household with reliable porch visibility may gain more from better access control, while a household with a solid lock may gain more from a clear view outside.

Think about who uses the entry most often. Family members, guests, cleaners, carers, couriers and neighbours can create very different needs at the same front door.

A smart lock suits people who want to share keys more carefully. A video doorbell suits people who want to screen visitors and deliveries before opening the door.

The rest of this guide looks closer at the Schlage Encode lock and the aosu doorbell. Their controls, power and limits should make the first purchase clearer.

What does a smart lock do better?

A smart lock is the better first upgrade when you need controlled entry without handing out physical keys. It can also help you manage access for family members, guests and service visits.

The Schlage Encode Smart WiFi Deadbolt Lock with Camelot Trim, Satin Nickel, supports up to 100 access codes when paired with the Schlage Home app and connected to a secure Wi-Fi network. It also supports remote lock and open control, lock history and customizable notifications.

Its built-in alarm can be customized for door movement and forced entry attempts. Auto-lock can relock the door after a selected delay, or you can turn it off.

The lock uses 4 AA batteries, which are included, and offers up to 6 months of battery life with typical use. A low-battery indicator appears on the touchscreen and in the Schlage Home app.

Installation uses a screwdriver and does not require hardwiring. Before choosing it, measure the door thickness and backset.

It fits doors from 1-3/8 in to 1-3/4 in thick with a 2-3/8 in or 2-3/4 in backset.

For a broader look at keypad access, app control and door fit, read our guide to smart door locks.

What does a video doorbell do better?

A video doorbell is the better first upgrade when the front door is your blind spot. It gives you a way to see visitors, deliveries and motion before deciding whether to answer.

The aosu 5MP Ultra HD Wireless & Wired Video Doorbell Camera records in 5MP and has a 166° wide view with vertical framing designed to show visitors from head to toe and packages near the ground.

It combines radar, PIR infrared sensing and AI human recognition. Customizable zones let you focus alerts on the areas that matter around the porch.

The aosuBase Mini includes 8GB built-in storage with 60-day loop recording. The doorbell supports local video playback without a subscription, while optional cloud plans are available for extra features and longer storage.

Power is flexible. You can use the battery for a simpler installation or wired power for continuous operation without recharging.

The doorbell has IP66 weather resistance and supports 2.4GHz and 5GHz Wi-Fi.

The trade-off is that wireless operation needs battery care. Its energy-saving design may also require a brief wake-up, so motion timing can vary with distance, angle and obstructions.

Our guide to the best keyless entry door locks with camera can help if you want to compare entry control with built-in or nearby camera coverage.

Should you control the door or watch the porch first?

Start with the device that addresses a repeated daily problem. A smart lock is more useful for access mistakes, while a video doorbell is more useful for missed visitors and uncertain deliveries.

Choose a smart lock first if:

  • You regularly wonder whether the door is locked.
  • You need separate access codes for different people.
  • You want to lock or open the door through an app.
  • You want lock history and customizable notifications.
  • You want an auto-lock option after leaving.

Choose a video doorbell first if:

  • You miss deliveries or visitors.
  • You want to speak with someone without opening the door.
  • You need a wider view of the doorstep.
  • You want recorded video for activity around the entrance.
  • You prefer to check the porch before deciding how to respond.

A smart lock can improve control after someone is authorized to enter. A video doorbell can improve your information before you respond.

Which Schlage Encode trim should you choose?

Choose the Camelot satin nickel version for a traditional trim style, or the Century matte black version for a darker door hardware look. Their listed access and alarm functions are closely aligned.

The Schlage Encode Smart WiFi Deadbolt Lock with Century Trim, Matte Black, supports up to 100 access codes, remote app control, lock history, notifications and voice control with Alexa and Google Home when paired as required.

This version uses four included AA batteries and offers up to 6 months of battery life with typical use. It fits standard doors from 1-3/8 in to 1-3/4 in thick and uses a 2-3/8 in or 2-3/4 in backset.

The practical difference here is appearance and listed connectivity. The Century model lists Bluetooth and Wi-Fi, while the Camelot model lists Wi-Fi.

Check the door measurements and hardware style before choosing between them.

If you want to compare a lock and a doorbell in one planning step, see how to choose a smart lock with a doorbell.

When does a wired doorbell need a transformer?

A wired video doorbell needs a suitable power supply, and an underpowered circuit can call for a transformer replacement. This is a power question, not a reason to choose a camera over a smart lock.

The Hardwired Transformer for Ring Wired Video Doorbells accepts 120V AC at 60 Hz and provides 16V 30VA output. It is designed to replace an older or underpowered transformer and works with the listed Ring wired doorbell models.

It does not record video, detect visitors or control a deadbolt. It only supports the power side of a compatible wired doorbell setup.

Follow the installation instructions and use appropriate electrical care. If you are unsure about the existing wiring or transformer, arrange qualified help rather than guessing at the connection.

Smart lock vs video doorbell for renters and guests

Renters should check permission and installation limits before choosing either device. A battery-operated smart lock or doorbell may avoid some wiring work, but door and lease rules still matter.

The Schlage locks install with a screwdriver and do not require hardwiring. The aosu doorbell can run on battery power or wired power, giving you more flexibility at the entry.

For guest access, a smart lock offers a clearer control model because you can issue an access code and remove it later. A doorbell helps you identify the guest, but it does not grant entry.

Keep the physical backup key for the smart lock in a secure place. For a broader comparison of alarm features in door hardware, read about best door locks with alarms.

What should you buy first if you plan to own both?

Buy the smart lock first when entry control is urgent, then add the video doorbell for outside awareness. Buy the video doorbell first when visitor monitoring is the missing piece, then add the smart lock later.

A two-device setup can divide the jobs cleanly. The doorbell handles the outside view and conversation, while the lock handles authorized entry and access history.

Plan the devices around the same entrance. Check Wi-Fi coverage, door measurements, available wiring and the places where you expect to receive alerts.

Do not assume that matching voice assistants makes every action work together. Confirm the exact app and smart-home setup before you depend on an automated routine.

You can also review best Eufy smart locks with cameras if you want to explore products that combine or connect these functions more closely.

Smart lock vs video doorbell: final decision

Pick a smart lock first if your priority is controlling who can enter and when. Pick a video doorbell first if your priority is seeing, hearing and recording activity at the door.

That order depends on the weak point in your current entry setup.

The Schlage Encode models are the stronger fit for remote entry, access codes and lock history. They suit homes where keys, guest access, missed locking or shared entry create the main daily problem.

The aosu doorbell is the stronger fit for 5MP doorstep video, local recording and flexible power. It suits homes where visitors, deliveries and porch activity are hard to see or judge from inside.

If you already have a reliable lock but no view of the porch, buy the video doorbell. That choice adds awareness without changing how the door is locked or opened.

If you can see the door but still manage keys, missed locking or guest access poorly, buy the smart lock first. That choice adds control without pretending a lock can show you the visitor outside.

Think about the first week after purchase, not only the first day. A smart lock will affect how family members and guests enter, while a video doorbell will affect how often you check alerts and review clips.

Think about upkeep too. A battery smart lock needs fresh batteries and occasional checks, while a battery doorbell needs recharging and attention to motion settings.

For the smart lock, check door thickness, backset, Wi-Fi coverage and battery access before ordering. For the video doorbell, check mounting position, view of the doorstep, Wi-Fi signal and whether battery or wired power suits the site.

Privacy should be part of the decision as well. Access codes and lock records are sensitive, and doorstep video can capture people who approach the home for ordinary reasons.

A sensible plan is to fix the most repeated problem first, use that device for a while, and then decide whether the second device is still needed. If both gaps are clear, the devices can work as a pair, with the doorbell handling outside awareness and the lock handling authorized entry and access history.

Frequently asked questions

Should I buy a smart lock or video doorbell first?

Buy a smart lock first when you need remote entry control, temporary access codes or lock history. Buy a video doorbell first when your main concern is seeing visitors and deliveries.

If you often miss people at the door, monitoring may provide more immediate value.

Can a smart lock replace a video doorbell?

No. A smart lock controls and records access activity, but it does not show who is standing outside.

A video doorbell adds visitor video, motion alerts and two-way audio, but it does not open the door by itself.

Can a video doorbell open the door?

A video doorbell does not replace a smart lock. It can help you identify and speak with a visitor, while a compatible smart lock handles entry control through a keypad or app.

Treat these as separate jobs unless you choose a combined system.

Is a smart lock harder to install than a video doorbell?

Installation depends on the door, wiring and exact model. The Schlage Encode locks use four AA batteries and need a compatible standard door, while the aosu doorbell supports battery or wired power.

A Ring wired setup may also need a suitable transformer.